Meeting of the Canadian Section of the IVR
Carleton University in Ottawa
Sunday, May 24, 2009.
For 2009 the international meeting in Beijing the IVR has chosen
as its theme “Global Harmony and the Rule of Law.” The
Canadian Section of the IVR has adopted related themes for its
meeting in Ottawa. The following themes are suggested, though work
in progress is also welcome.
Topics for the Ottawa 2009 Meeting:
- The Nature of International Law
- Regulating Economic Markets
- National Identity in Global Context
- Environmental Law
- Women and Global Justice
- Free Speech and Ethnic Diversity
Dates:
- Due by Friday, February 6, 2009: Commitment to circulate a
principal paper or commentary.
- Due by Friday, April 24: Principal papers.
- Due by Friday, May 16: Commentaries.
- Meeting on May 24th
To help with organizing, please send to nbrett@dal.ca a note
indicating that you intend to present a principal paper or
commentary as soon as you know that you are planning to attend.
Titles or subjects of papers would also be appreciated. A reminder
will be sent in early February.
Papers and commentaries should be sent to the same address.
Details about the website will be sent in a future
communication.
Please forward this to others who may be interested.
Nathan Brett (nbrett@dal.ca)
Executive Director
Canadian Section: IVR
Preliminary Schedule
Carleton University, Ottawa Ontario
Sunday, May 24, 2009
Location: MacOdrum
Library Room 360
PDF version of this Schedule (for printing)
9:00 Introductions
Free Speech and Ethnic
Diversity
9:05 Alistair Macleod (Queens) "Free Speech, Equality of
Opportunity, and Justice."
9:30 Joe Ellin (W. Michigan) "Are Free Speech And Multicultural
Diversity Compatible?"
- Comment: Chris Gray, Nathan Brett, Marc
Ramsay
9:55 Mohamad Al-Hakim (York): Subject: Hate Crime
10:20 SHORT Break 10 Minutes
Markets,
Environmental Law, Global Justice
10:30 Wes Cragg (York) Sustainability and Human Rights
10:55 Albert Spalding (Wayne State) "Can (Enforceable) Minimum
Ethical Standards for Accountants be Established Globally?"
11: 20 Lucan Gregory (McGill) The ICJ Nuclear Weapons Advisory
Opinion
11:45 Annual Business Meeting
12:15 Lunch
International Law
and The Nature of law
1:30 Bill Conklin (Windsor) "The International Community of
Peremptory Norms"
1:55 John-Otto Phillips (McMaster) "Legal Positivism and a Third
Category of Judicial Obligation"
2:20 Courtney Hamara (McMaster) "The Concept of the Rule of
Law."
- Comment: Colin Macleod, Mohamad Al-Hakim
Women and Global
Justice
2:45 Ami Harbin (Dalhousie University) "Vulnerability and
Forward-Looking Responsibility after Young"
- Comment: Mohamad Al-Hakim, Colin MacLeod
3:10 Meredith Schwartz, (Dalhousie University) "Responsibility
and Respect: Using a Social Connection Model of Responsibility in
the Context of Health Inequalities"
3:35 SHORT Break 10 Minutes
Other Work in
Progress
3:45 David Rondel (McMaster) "On the Logic of Moral
Congruence"
- Comment: Alistair McLeod, Colin MacLeod
4:10 Marc Ramsay (Acadia) "The Moral Standing of the Human
Embryo: A Criticism of the Twinning and Fusion Arguments"
4:35 Susan Dimock (York) "The Responsibility of Intoxicated
Offenders"
5:00 END
7:00 Dinner
Note: Often participants who circulate papers also provide one
or two short commentaries. In addition, the following have
volunteered to act as commentators:
- Nathan Brett (Dalhousie)
- Michael Hinds (McMaster)
- Norman Madarasz (UGF, Brazil)
- Joshua Mildenberger (McMaster)
- François Tanguay-Renaud (Osgoode)
- Christopher Gray (Concordia)
- Colin Macleod (Victoria)
PAPERS RECEIVED
- Mohamad Al-Hakim, "Agent Responsibility in Hate Motivated Crimes"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Wesley Cragg, "Sustainability, Business Ethics, and Human Rights:
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- William E. Conklin, "The International Community of Peremptory Norms"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Susan Dimock "The Responsibility of Intoxicated
Offenders"
(NOTE: Full paper is posted. See note at beginning.)
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Joe Ellin "Are Free Speech And Multicultural Diversity Compatible?"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Lucan Gregory "Loopholes, Legal Gaps, and Supreme Emergencies: Rethinking the Nuclear Advisory Opinion"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Ami Harbin "Vulnerability and Forward-Looking Responsibility after Young"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Courtney Hamara "The Concept of the Rule of Law"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Alistair Macleod, "Free Speech, Equal Opportunity, and Justice"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- John Ott-Phillips, "Legal Positivism and a Third Category of Judicial Obligation"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Marc Ramsay, "The Moral Standing of the Human Embryo: A
Criticism of the Twinning and Fusion Arguments"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- David Rondel, "The Logic of Moral Congruence: G.A. Cohen on Equality and Justice"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Meredith Schwartz "Trust and Responsibility in Health Policy"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Albert Spalding, "Can (Enforceable) Minimum Ethical Standards for Accountants be Established Globally?"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
COMMENTARIES RECEIVED
- Mohamed Al-Hakim, "Comments on Courtney Hamara"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Nathan Brett, "Comments on Mohamed Al-Hakim"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Nathan Brett, "Comments on Joe Ellin"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Christopher Gray, "Comments on Joe Ellin"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Christopher Gray, "Brief Comments on AlHakim, Cameron,Conklin, Dimock, Gregory,
Harbin, Hamara, Ott-Philips;
Ramsay, Schwartz, Spaulding, MacLeod and Rondel"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Courtney Hamara, "Comments on John Otto-Phillips"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Alistair MacLeod, "Comments on Wesley Cragg"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Alistair MacLeod, "Comments on David Rondel"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Colin MacLeod, "Comments on Amy Harbin"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Colin MacLeod, "Comments on Courtney Hamara"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Colin MacLeod, "Comments on David Rondel"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- Marc Ramsay, "Comments on Joe Ellin
PDF:
WORD:
RTF:
- David Rondel, "Comments on Alistair MacLeod"
PDF:
WORD:
RTF: